After reading Doubt is Their Product, by David Michaels, we are well aware of the insufficient regulation of harmful substances, especially here in the US. The common trend has been to wait for an epidemic to occur, and then action is taken to regulate the substance, opposed to discovering possible harms of the substance before it is widely used or regulating the substance as soon as any harms can be associated with it. With this knowledge, I was very elated to hear the words of Desiree Plata:
Now we’re trying to be a little smarter about the process and ask ourselves environmentally relevant questions early: Are these materials toxic? How best should we use them? And how can we prevent them from becoming a problem and still take advantage of their exceptional market applications?
Yes, these are wonderful words to hear indeed. The sad thing is that it has taken so long for humans to learn from their mistakes in this field, but it appears we can now have hope that we are progressing to more environmentally and health conscious industrial and economic practices.
But, if this class has taught me one thing it is to be skeptical — are the practices of harmful substance regulation really improving? One can only hope so. How are we to know if industries, like the tobacco industry, are still wheeling and dealing behind the backs of the consumers? It is really kind of like cheating, as the acts of creating uncertainty when the harms are most certainly known are, in fact, acts of deception (to deceive is in a definition of “cheat”). And as Eric Weiner, and the author David Callahan he mentions, suggest, cheating is part of our american culture (npr). When something is deeply rooted in culture is it impossible to reverse? If not impossible, it is stupendously difficult to do, as is obvious from the slow progression of regulating harmful substances to the benefit of environmental health (including human health).
This relates to the steroid section of the “Chemistry of Baseball” podcast. Gregg Valentino, the man who holds the record for the world’s largest biceps, also known as “the man whose arms exploded,” a steroid abuser, said that “steroids are as American as apple pie,” in an ESPN interview. Eric Weiner mentions the use of steroids (a form of cheating in) in the article I linked above, saying it is nothing new to tilt the level playing field. Apparently it has been happening since the days of the Ancient Greeks, and it is still occurring today. Furthermore, regardless of the usage of steroids in sports, attendance at sporting events is increasing, according to Weiner. Maybe if these steroids give the American people the entertainment they want to see, they don’t care too much. Just as the profitable production of harmful substances may provide useful products or be an economical booster, and thus be allowed to persist.
So, I do not know for certain that the situation is improving, like Desiree Plata stated, but we can be certain that anything deeply embedded in the American culture has a hard time squeezing its way out. Lets hope we can conquer this American way and make her words come true, going against the norm in order to obtain a healthier environment in which to live in.